Where to Eat in Long Island NY, Montauk

About Long Island NY, Montauk - Where to Stay - What to Do - Where to Eat

Montauk offers a variety of dining options, from casual seafood shacks to upscale restaurants, highlighting fresh local ingredients and coastal flavors. Here are some popular places to eat in Montauk, Long Island:

Seafood and Casual Dining:

  1. Gosman's Dock:

    • A waterfront institution offering fresh seafood with views of Montauk Harbor.
    • Features multiple dining options including casual outdoor dining at Gosman's Clam Bar.
  2. The Lobster Roll (Lunch):

    • Known locally as "Lunch," this iconic restaurant serves classic lobster rolls and seafood dishes in a relaxed atmosphere.
  3. West Lake Clam & Chowder House:

    • Offers casual dining with a focus on seafood, including clam chowder, steamers, and lobster dinners.
  4. Duryea's Lobster Deck:

    • Located on Fort Pond Bay, known for its lobster rolls and seafood platters with scenic waterfront views.

Upscale Dining:

  1. Scarpetta Beach:

    • Located at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, this restaurant offers Italian-inspired cuisine with ocean views.
  2. The Crow's Nest:

    • A waterfront restaurant offering a seasonal menu with fresh seafood, local produce, and craft cocktails.

Casual Eateries and Cafes:

  1. Navy Beach:

    • A beachfront restaurant serving American cuisine with a focus on fresh seafood and locally sourced ingredients.
  2. Montauk Brewing Company:

    • While primarily known for its craft beer, Montauk Brewing Company also offers food trucks and pop-up eateries on-site.

American Cuisine:

  1. Swallow East:

    • Offers American fare with a focus on local seafood, along with live music and a lively atmosphere.
  2. Shagwong Tavern:

    • A historic tavern serving American comfort food and seafood dishes in a casual setting.

Breakfast and Brunch:

  1. Joni's Kitchen:

    • Known for its healthy and organic breakfast options, including smoothies, acai bowls, and breakfast wraps.
  2. Naturally Good Foods & Cafe:

    • Offers organic and vegetarian-friendly breakfast and brunch options, including smoothies, sandwiches, and salads.

Food Trucks and Quick Bites:

  1. The Lobster Roll Truck (Amagansett):

    • Offers the famous lobster rolls from "Lunch" in a food truck format, perfect for quick bites by the beach.
  2. Tacombi Montauk:

    • A taco truck serving authentic Mexican street food, including tacos, quesadillas, and agua frescas.

These dining options reflect Montauk's diverse culinary scene, catering to various tastes and preferences while highlighting fresh seafood and local ingredients. Whether you're looking for a waterfront dining experience, casual eats by the beach, or a fine dining meal with ocean views, Montauk offers something for every palate.